1. Leaf cells with central papillae 11.P. yezoana
Philonotis yezoana is
distinguished by its slender habit and the upper leaf cells with a
central papilla. Although some species of the genus may have single
cells with central papillae, the majority of their cells have the
mammillae/papillae at proximal or distal ends of the cells. The
species is known in Russia only in the Far East, where it is rather
rare in Kamchatka, Kuril Islands, Sakhalin and Primorsky Territory.
— Leaf cells with
mammillae/papillae on either lower or upper cell ends, occasionally
with central papillae in some cells 2
2. Upper leaf cells with mammillae/papillae at lower cell ends; lower
leaf border with double-crenulate teeth (i.e., two adjoining
cells form a tooth) 3
— Upper leaf cells with
mammillae/papillae at upper cell ends; lower leaf border entire,
serrate or serrulate 10
3. Leaves ranked in five distinct spiral rows 4
— Leaves not ranked in
distinct rows 5
4. Leaves falcate, secund, ovate, gradually acute; costae usually
coarsely mammillose at back ± throughout 9.P. seriata
The five ranked leaves in
Philonotis seriata are best seen on fresh specimens in the
field. Its bulging costae are much stronger than those of P. fontana and they have large colourless mammillae on the dorsal
surface (best seen in side view). The costae of related species have
only small papillae or scindulae. Philonotis seriata is known
from a few mountain (Urals, Altai, West Sayans, Khibiny) and lowland
(Yamal, valley of Yenissey) localities. It grows in spring mires and
spring-fed brooks in areas with siliceous bedrock.
— Leaves spirally twisted,
from broadly ovate base abruptly acuminate; costae rarely coarsely
mammillose 8.P. americana
Plants of Philonotis
americana have a distinctive aspect due to their twisted,
non-imbricate leaves, and as a result its brownish stems are visible
between the leaves. The wet leaves of P. americana differ
from the wet leaves of P. seriata in being straight or
slightly secund rather than falcate. This species has only recently
been found in Asia: Kamchatka, Kuril Islands, Sakhalin, and Japan.
5. Leaf cells pellucid, smooth or low-mammillose; leaf margins plain
or revolute; upper leaf cells as wide as lower leaf cells or
somewhat narrower 6
— Leaf cells opaque or only
basal leaf cells ± pellucid, distinctly mammillose/papillose; leaf
margins recurved or revolute; upper leaf cells clearly narrower
(–1/3) than lower leaf cells 7
6. Leaves erect, plicate or smooth, triangular, ovate or broadly
ovate; leaf apices shortly acute or obtuse; leaf margins plain or
recurved; costae strong; leaf cells quadrate, rectangular or
rhomboidal, usually thin-walled; apical cells narrowly elongate or
vermicular, thick-walled; inner perigonial leaves short acute or
obtuse 6.P. fontana, male plants
— Leaves usually secund,
smooth, ovate; leaf apices acute, leaf margins plane or narrowly
recurved; costae narrow; leaf cells rectangular or rhomboidal, cells
at apiculus + rectangular, all leaf cells +
thin-walled; inner perigonial leaves acuminate 5.P. caespitosa
Dried specimens of Philonotis
caespitosa remain pale-green, while specimens of the other
species of section Philonotis turn yellowish to brownish when
dried. Important microscopic characters of P. caespitosa include
weakly serrate leaf margins; non-plicate leaves; and lax leaf
areolation. The leaves of P. caespitosa are much more
translucent than those of related species with linear or vermicular
apical cells. When identifying collections of P. fontana and
P. caespitosa only fully grown, old stems from the previous
growing season should be used. Philonotis fontana differs
from P. caespitosa in having broadly ovate, erect leaf bases
± abruptly narrowed to slender acumina, strongly recurved leaf
margins and plicate leaves. In contrast P. caepitosa has
ovate, spreading to flexuose leaves, gradually tapered acumina,
plane or narrowly recurved leaf margins, and smooth leaves. In
Russia, P. caespitosa has been confirmed only from its
European regions.
7. Stem
tips with spiraling leaves; leaves twisted when dry, diverging from
stems at wide angles 8.P. americana
— Stem tips with straight
or falcate-secund; leaves straight when dry, erect or spreading at
base 8
8. Plants
robust; leaves (1.5–)1.8–3.0 mm long; costae 60–125(–200) µm
wide near base; juxtacostal cells at widest part of leaf mostly
48–100 µm long, narrowly rectangular, thin-walled, pellucid;
perigonial leaves acute 10.P. calcarea
Philonotis calcarea has
large, rather stiff plants with narrowly elongate basal leaf cells. The species occurs sporadically in Europaean Russia from the
northern regions to the Caucasus, as well as isolated localities in
the Altai.
— Plants tiny to moderately
robust; leaves (0.5–) 1–2 mm long; costae 25–80 µm wide near
base; juxtacostal cells at widest part of leaf 24–40 µm long,
quadrate, rectangular or rhomboidal, thin- to firm-walled, pellucid
or opaque; perigonial leaves obtuse or acute 9
9. Stems compactly tufted; leaves tapering from ovate bases to
acuminate or cuspidate, straight or slightly flexuose apices; leaf
acumina bending in different directions; costae excurrent to
long-excurrent; basal leaf cells opaque, firm-walled ± rectangular;
inner perigonial leaves acute 7.P. tomentella
Philonotis
tomentella is a more
northern species than P. fontana, where it
replaces P. fontana in
permafrost regions. However, the two species sometimes occur
together in montane regions, although P. tomentella usually
occurs at higher elevations than P. fontana.
— Stems loosely tufted;
leaves tapering from broadly ovate bases to acute or acuminate
apices, leaf acumina one-sidedly secund (especially at stem apices);
costae percurrent or scarcely excurrent (rarely long-excurrent);
basal leaf cells ± pellucid, thin-walled, quadrate, rectangular or
rhomboidal; inner perigonial leaves obtuse to short-acute 6.P. fontana
There
are many key differences between Philonotis
fontana and P. tomentella. Nevertheless
separating these two species is not easy because many collections
have imperfectly developed plants that are difficult to evaluate. The presence of obtuse inner perigonial leaves in P. fontana has been used
to separate it from P. tomentella which has
acute to acuminate inner perigonial leaves. Even though this
difference has been emphasized in many floras, a more reliable
distinction between the two species seems to be stem leaf form below
the perigonia. In P. fontana these leaves
are often straight and have short acute or obtuse apices, contrary
to secund leaves with longer acumina on female and sterile shoots. In contrast, these leaves in P. tomentella do not
differ as much from the vegetative leaves on female and sterile
shoots. Overall, P. fontana is the most
common species of the genus in Russia, however in the Arctic zone it
is nearly absent.
10(2). Autoicous with bud-like perigonia below perichaetia; costae strong,
excurrent 3. P. rigida
Known in Russia from a single
collection in the Black Sea coastal area of the Caucasus. It is
strikingly different from all other species of the genus in having
rigid plants; narrow leaves; strongly excurrent costae; and an
autoicous sexual condition. Russian (and Georgian) plants of P. rigida differ from West European in longer leaves, 2.0–2.8 vs. 1.0–1.6(–2.0) mm, thus further study on their identity is
needed.
— Dioicous; costae slender,
percurrent to short excurrent 11
11. Plants
tiny, 0.5–2.0 cm tall, thread-like; stems upright or procumbent;
leaves straight, linear-lanceolate, slightly concave, not in rows;
leaf cells mammillose/papillose at upper cell ends or bulging at
lower cell ends at leaf base and mammillose/papillose in upper cells
end at leaf apices 4. P. capillaris
Philonots capillaris can
be characterized by its: very slender thread-like aspect; lax,
pellucid, thin-walled leaf cells; low mammillae/papillae at the
upper cell ends; and upper/lower leaf cells that are ± the same
width. It closely resembles P. caespitosa, but that species
has mammillae at the lower cell ends, while in P. capillaris the leaf cells have papillae at the upper ends or bulging at the
lower ends only at the base of the leaves. Further studies may
reveal that P. capillaris, as circumscribed here, includes
other cryptic species. Philonots capillaris is rare in
Russia, known only from a few collections in the Caucasus, Yakutia,
Commander Islands, and Amurskaya Province.
— Plants medium-sized,
1–5(–9) cm tall, not thread-like; stems upright; leaves
falcate-secund, ovate-lanceolate or triangular-lanceolate; gradually
tapered to acute or acuminate apices, concave or keeled, often
distinctly in five rows, leaf cells mammillose/papillose at upper
cell ends 12
12. Leaves
widely spaced, slightly keeled to concave; marginal teeth single;
costae 50–75 µm wide at base; brood branch stalks long, leaflets
acuminate 2. P. marchica
The leaves of Philonotis
marchica are more weakly keeled than those of P. falcata,
have narrower costae, and consistently single marginal teeth. In
addition, the basal leaf cell papillae appear to be higher than
those of P. falcata and the cells are narrower. As a result
the basal leaf cells are more opaque than the pellucid basal leaf
cells of P. falcata. Most collections of P. marchica are from European Russia. The species is also known from a few
localities in the Caucasus and Kuril Islands.
— Leaves imbricate,
strongly carinate; marginal teeth single and/or double; costae
75–100 µm wide at base; brood branch stalks short, leaflets
acute 1. P. falcata
The best diagnostic features
ofP. falcata are its strongly carinate leaves that are often
clearly arranged in rows, and leaf cells with mammillae/papillae at
the upper ends. At times the leaves are somewhat distantly spaced
and this obscures their arrangement in the rows. But these plants
typically have innovations with clearly ranked, immature leaves
(best seen when wet). Philonotis falcata is often
misidentified as P. seriata, another species with leaves in
five rows. Philonotis seriata is distinguished from P. falcata by the presence of mammillae/papillae at the lower ends
of the leaf cells. Philonotis falcata has a general East
Asian distribution, but it is never common. There are
scattered collections of it as far as west as the Caucasus and
as far east as the eastern part of Yakutia. In the Altai it occurs
from 400 to 2200 m>m elev.